Great, but not that great.
To be fair, this animation is only rated an f'ing 4 out of 5 because the Swainy has a very high reputation. The animation itself isnt actually that brilliant! OK, the characterization was pretty good, but taking pictures instead of drawing it yourself? That alone brings the score down to at most 3 -- that's something only an amateur like me would do, and ive only done that once!! This is a classic example of BAD RATING in the portal, and I was expecting much higher of an animation like this.
Don't get me wrong -- I think you're a brilliantly skilled animator, but this is just one of your early works -- what you did when u were at my level It's just down to luck and how good the rest of the series was that this less-good toon got such a disproportionately high score.
That count as constructive criticism...?
6/10
-DALViEL.